Question:
Sentence 1: "The painting in Mark's living room shows an oak tree. It is to the right of the bookcase."
Sentence 2: "The painting is to the right of the bookcase."
Is sentence 2 true, based on sentence 1?

ANS:
yes

Question:
Sentence 1: "Tom said "Check" to Ralph as he took his bishop."
Sentence 2: "Tom said "Check" to Ralph as he took Tom's bishop."
Is sentence 2 true, based on sentence 1?

ANS:
no

Question:
Sentence 1: "Jim comforted Kevin because he was so upset."
Sentence 2: "Jim was so upset."
Is sentence 2 true, based on sentence 1?

ANS:
no

Question:
Sentence 1: "When Tatyana reached the cabin, her mother was sleeping. She was careful not to disturb her , undressing and climbing back into her berth."
Sentence 2: "She was careful not to disturb her mother , undressing and climbing back into her berth."
Is sentence 2 true, based on sentence 1?
ANS:
yes