CS372H Spring 2011 Homework 12 Solutions

Problem 1

Consider the following piece of code which multiplies two matrices:
int a[1024][1024], b[1024][1024], c[1024][1024];
   unsigned i, j, k;
   for(i = 0; i < 1024; i++)
       for(j = 0; j < 1024; j++)
           for(k = 0; k < 1024; k++)
               c[i][j] += a[i,k] * b[k,j];
Assume that the binary for executing this function fits in one page, and the stack also fits in one page. Assume further that an integer requires 4 bytes for storage. Compute the number of TLB misses if the page size is 4096 and the TLB has 8 entries with a replacement policy consisting of LRU.

1024*(2+1024*1024) = 1073743872
The binary and the stack each fit in one page, thus each takes one entry in the TLB. While the function is running, it is accessing the binary page and the stack page all the time. So the two TLB entries for these two pages would reside in the TLB all the time and the data can only take the remaining 6 TLB entries.

We assume the two entries are already in TLB when the function begins to run. Then we need only consider those data pages.

Since an integer requires 4 bytes for storage and the page size is 4096 bytes, each array requires 1024 pages. Suppose each row of an array is stored in one page. Then these pages can be represented as a[0..1023], b[0..1023], c[0..1023]: Page a[0] contains the elements a[0][0..1023], page a[1] contains the elements a[1][0..1023], etc.

For a fixed value of i, say 0, the function loops over j and k, we have the following reference string:

a[0], b[0], c[0], a[0], b[1], c[0], ¡ a[0], b[1023], c[0]
a[0], b[0], c[0], a[0], b[1], c[0], ¡ a[0], b[1023], c[0]
For the reference string (1024 rows in total), a[0], c[0] will contribute two TLB misses. Since a[0] and b[0] each will be accessed every four memory references, the two pages will not be replaced by the LRU algorithm. For each page in b[0..1023], it will incur one TLB miss every time it is accessed. So the number of TLB misses for the second inner loop is
2+1024*1024 = 1048578
So the total number of TLB misses is 1024*1048578 = 1073743872

Problem 2

  1. A computer system has a page size of 1,024 bytes and maintains the page table for each process in main memory. The overhead required for doing a lookup in the page table is 500 ns. To recude this overhead, the comnputer has a TLB that caches 32 virtual pages to physical frame mappings. A TLB lookup requires 100ns. What TLB hit-rate is required to ensure an average virtual address translation time of 200ns?

    Need solution.

  2. Discuss the issues involved in picking a page size for a virtual memory system.
    1. Name one issue that argues for small page sizes? Name two that argue for large page sizes?
    2. How do the characteristics of disks influence the selection of a page size?


    1. Need solution
    2. Need solution

Problem 3

Consider a system with a virtual address size of 64MB (2^26), a physical memory of size 2GB (2^31), and a page size of 1K (2^10). Under the target workload, 32 processes (2^5) are running; half of the processes are smaller than 8K (2^13) and half use the full 64MB virtual address space. Each page has 4 control bits.
  1. What is the size of a single top-level page table entry (and why)?

  2. What is the size of a single bottom-level page table entry (and why)?

  3. If you had to choose between two arrangements of page table: 2-level and 3-level, which would you choose and why? Compute the expected space overhead for each variation: State the space overhead for each small process and each large process. Then compute the total space overhead for the entire system.