J/A 1 - Yes
this position can be reached legally - see Part B below.
Part A:
Let's determine
who made the last move through the process of elimination:
1. First
note that the White King was the last piece to enter the logjam on the
1st thru 4th ranks, since all the other pieces in that entire sector are
blocked by it.
2. Furthermore,
note that all the pieces must've made their way into the logjam before
the e7xf6 capture, otherwise the White King couldn't have made it to the
f4 square.
3. Therefore
Black's h8 Rook needed to escape via h6 at some earlier point, eliminating
h5 as the last move.
4. Since
the White King was sent to the f4 square at the same time the Black's f8
Bishop was freed by the e7xf6 capture, and since the Bishop still needed
to get to a7, the White King couldn't have made the final move.
The only remaining
possibilities are White's Knight, White's Pawn on a3, or Black's dark-squared
Bishop.
5. Since
the White King is a sitting duck against any Bishop checks on the h2-b8
diagonal, the White Knight must have blocked checks for two successive
moves as the Bishop moved through c7 and b8 on its way to the a7 square.
6. The only
way the Knight could've blocked for two moves in a row is if White played
the temporizing move a2-a3 as the Bishop moved to b8, so the pawn move
is eliminated.
7. With
only the Knight and Bishop as candidates, the only way to reach the final
position is:
...
Bc7+
Nd6
Bb8
a3
Ba7
Ne8*
Bb8+
Nc7
Ba7
* or Nb5
So, in the diagrammed
position, it must be White's move.
Part B:
Finding a sequence
of moves to reach the diagrammed position:
The theoretical
minimum number of moves required to reach the diagrammed position is 39,
limited by the longer distance required for Black to move his pieces to
the other side of the board.
At minimum, Black
needs to make the following moves:
King:
7 (Via c7)
Queen :
3 (Via
c7)
Rook1:
6 (The
one ending up on d2)
Rook2:
4 (The
one ending up on e3)
Knight1:
4
Knight2:
4
Bishop1:
7 (From Part A above, we know it must've moved
7 times, as follows, f8-e7-d8-c7-b8-a7-b8-a7)
Bishop2:
0
Pawns:
4 (a7xb6,
c7-c6, e7xf6, and h7-h5)
My best was 40
moves (one extra King move for Black). I don't believe 39 is possible,
since the perfect King path isn't available..
White
Black
1. e4
h5
2. d3
Rh6
3. Be3
Rf6
4. Bb6
axb6
5. Qg4
Nc6
6. Nf3
Nd4
7. Ne5
Rf3
8. Kd2
Re3
9. Kc3
Re2
10. Kc4
Rd2
11. Nc3
Nf3
12. Be2
Ra5
13. Rhf1
Ng1
14. Qh4
c6
15. Ng6
Rf5
16. Rae1
Rf3
17. Bd1
Re3
18. Nh8
Qc7
19. Re2
Qg3
20. f4
Qe1
21. Rf3
Nh6
22. Qf2
Nf5
23. Ng6
Ng3
24. Ne5
Nf1
25. Kd4
Kd8
26. g3
Kc7
27. Nb1
Kd6
28. Nc4+
Ke6
29. f5+
Kf6
30. Nc3
Kg5
31. Ke5
Kg4
32. Nd5
Kh3
33. Nf6
exf6+
34. Kf4
Be7
35. Nd6
Bd8
36. Ne8
Bc7+
37. Nd6
Bb8
38. a3
Ba7
39. Ne8
Bb8+
40. Nc7
Ba7