[FOM] A question about AC in constructive mathematics

Arnon Avron aa at tau.ac.il
Sat Apr 28 17:26:06 EDT 2018


Recently I came across a theorem (and a proof) that 
AC implies the law of excluded middle in constructive
mathematics, implying that AC should be rejected
by intuitionists. I was surprised, since AC seems to me 
to be valid according to the BHK interpretation of the
logical constants, and is a indeed a theorem in Martin-Lö's 
intuitionistic type theoy.  Also Bishop wrote in his book 
that AC is valid from a constructive point of view.

 I'll be very grateful if one of the specialists here on FOM
clarifies this issue for me.

Thanks,

Arnon Avron


More information about the FOM mailing list